The UN International Court of Justice in The Hague is now in session, addressing a legal dispute initiated by the Republic of South Africa (RSA) against Israel for potential genocide in the Gaza Strip. This pivotal case revolves around the precautionary measures that the court can enforce to prevent further escalation while the substantive trial is underway.
South Africa officially filed the lawsuit against Israel on December 29, 2023, alleging a possible violation of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. The RSA contends that Israel's actions are indicative of genocide, specifically intending "to eradicate Palestinians in Gaza as part of a broader ethnic and national group." In addition to denouncing Israel's actions, South Africa seeks a court ruling demanding the cessation of hostilities in the Gaza Strip and reparations.
The court hearings, scheduled for January 11-12, will center on South Africa's plea for precautionary measures. During the proceedings, the South African representatives will be granted three hours to present their case on the first day, followed by an equal allotment of time for the Israeli side on the second day. The court's verdict on these measures is anticipated within a few weeks, bearing in mind that the court's rulings are binding, albeit without direct enforcement mechanisms.
Genocide or Self-Defense
The South African indictment, spanning over 80 pages, marshals eyewitness accounts, UN statements, and historical comparisons to assert that Israel is engaged in genocide against the Palestinian population in Gaza. The document posits that Israel's actions go beyond self-defense, citing a high death toll, forced displacement, and attacks on essential services as evidence. The indictment includes examples of direct and public incitement to genocide by Israeli government officials, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu: threats to make Gaza permanently uninhabitable, referring to Palestinians as "human animals" and more. Calls by Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich and National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir to expel Palestinians from Gaza are also mentioned.
Israel vehemently rejects the genocide accusations, asserting that the case lacks a legal basis and serves as political and legal cover for a Hamas attack in October 2023. The Israeli side emphasizes its right to self-defense, highlighting unprecedented measures taken to minimize civilian casualties in the Gaza Strip.
South Africa's Motivation: A Political and Historical Context
The lawsuit filed by South Africa stems from a UN call urging the international community "to prevent the risk of genocide against the Palestinian people." President Cyril Ramaphosa expressed solidarity with Palestinians shortly after Israel's Gaza operation, characterizing Israel as an "apartheid state." Last November, the South African parliament voted to close the Israeli embassy in Pretoria and sever diplomatic ties until a Gaza ceasefire is established.
South Africa's historical ties with Palestine trace back to the anti-apartheid era when the Palestine Liberation Organization supported Nelson Mandela's African National Congress. In contrast, Israel actively supported the apartheid regime despite international arms embargoes. Nelson Mandela, in 1997, underscored the interconnected struggles, stating, "We know too well that our freedom is incomplete without the freedom of the Palestinians".
GSV "Russia - Islamic World"
Photo: Racool_studio/Freepik
Based on materials from TASS